As Christmas rapidly approaches, Paula (Kimberley Sustad), a St. Louis antique appraiser, reluctantly accepts a marriage proposal from her workaholic attorney boyfriend, Daniel (Giles Panton).
When she tells her Aunt Jane (Kathie Lee Gifford), she senses that Paula
has mixed emotions over the engagement, and invites Paula to her Nantucket
home.
But upon her arrival, her Aunt explains that
she needs to meet with her publisher so Paula takes a day trip to the nearby
island of Martha's Vineyard where she meets Gery Conover (Paul Campbell), the kind hearted
and charming owner of the Charlotte Inn.
But when bad weather prevents her from
departing, Paula winds up staying at Gery's inn and enjoying the local holiday
festivities alongside him and they begin to have feelings for each other but
when the weather clears up, they part ways and Paula returns to Nantucket.
On her return Aunt Jane senses she's fallen
for Gery, and shares with Paula her belief that their meeting was God's way of “winking”
at her to help determine which direction her life should take.
But would Paula take the hint and accept that
she and Daniel were not compatible and that her future was with Gery on
Martha’s Vineyard.