Sisters Jennifer and Meg Swift (Kimberly Williams-Paisley and Ashley Williams) are incredibly close even though they live apart, widowed Jennifer in Salt Lake City with her son Simon (Jacob Buster) where she runs a popular restaurant.
Meg meanwhile remained in their hometown, Hazelwood, working at the
family bakery.
But as the first Christmas, since the death of their Uncle Dave (Kevin
Nealon), approaches things change.
Meg travels to the city to cover at the restaurant while Jennifer and
Simon return to Hazelwood for the holiday.
Once they are home and experience the warmth of family and the joys of
a hometown Christmas, they become obsessed with putting on one last Christmas
screening at the Madison, Jennifer’s late Uncle's old, dilapidated movie theatre
before it is sold.
However, its sorely in need of repair so she turns to her high school
crush Eric Baker (Mark Deklin) and of course the nostalgia of the theatre and
the magic of the holidays bring welcome romance.